Latin NCAP, Euro NCAP and NHTSA: what each program measures and why their stars are not equivalent

Stars from Latin NCAP, Euro NCAP and NHTSA are not equivalent: each program tests the cars of its own market with its own tests and criteria, and changes its protocol from time to time. This guide explains what each one measures, when comparing a result makes sense and how to check whether your car is the version that was tested.

What are Latin NCAP, Euro NCAP and NHTSA, and what does each one measure?

Latin NCAP, Euro NCAP and NHTSA are programs that test new cars and publish star ratings, each for a different market: Latin America and the Caribbean, Europe and the United States, respectively.

Latin NCAP rates cars sold in Latin America and the Caribbean from 0 to 5 stars based on four areas: adult occupant protection, child occupant protection, protection of pedestrians and other vulnerable road users, and safety assist systems.

Latin NCAP crash tests assess occupant protection in impact tests; the exact test conditions and the assistance systems that are assessed (such as electronic stability control, ESC, and autonomous emergency braking, AEB) depend on the protocol period, and are set out in the protocol documents that Latin NCAP publishes at latinncap.com.

Euro NCAP gives star ratings to cars sold in Europe, and each rating is valid for up to six years from the date it is awarded.

NHTSA, the US government road safety agency, rates models sold in the United States from 1 to 5 stars, by model year, for frontal crash, side crash and rollover resistance, plus an overall rating.

Can Latin NCAP, Euro NCAP and NHTSA stars be compared?

Not directly: each program uses its own tests and weights them differently, so the same number of stars does not mean the same thing in two programs.

Latin NCAP explains this in its frequently asked questions: its results up to and including 2019 cannot be compared with Euro NCAP results, and results from 2020 onward can only be compared in relative terms with Euro NCAP stars up to 2017, because the markets differ and each technology carries a different weight in the result.

NHTSA stars come from that program's own tests and describe the model sold in the United States, not the version sold in Latin America.

Euro NCAP warns that comparing ratings from different years is only meaningful if the changes to its rating system were minor.

Why does the test year matter?

The test year shows which protocol the car was rated under, and Latin NCAP says this is essential to interpret the result correctly: its tests are updated regularly, new tests are added and star levels are adjusted.

Latin NCAP has used four protocol periods: 2010–2015, 2016–2019, 2020–2025 and 2026–2029. The current one runs from January 1, 2026 to December 31, 2029 and adds, among other things, assessments of the adult in the rear seat and of the 10-year-old test dummy.

Latin NCAP states that no general equivalence can be drawn between the stars of one protocol and those of the next. That is why Vinfo.la always shows the year and protocol of each result and labels results from 2019 or earlier as “earlier protocol, not comparable”.

Latin NCAP results remain valid while they are published on its website, even under an earlier protocol. Euro NCAP, by contrast, treats a rating as valid for up to six years from the date it is awarded, and euroncap.com shows it as expired from January 1 of the seventh year after the test.

Why can a car with the same name be a different car?

Because a trade name does not guarantee the same vehicle: a model can be built in different plants, on another platform or with different safety equipment depending on the market.

Latin NCAP warns about this in its frequently asked questions: cars tested by other NCAP programs, even if they look the same as those in Latin America, may offer different safety, with differences ranging from equipment to construction (materials, reinforcements and welding). That is why it recommends checking the result from the local NCAP.

Latin NCAP tests the most basic version in terms of safety offered in any market in Latin America and the Caribbean: if a version with fewer airbags or without a given system is sold in any country, that is the version it rates.

Vinfo.la shows a Euro NCAP or NHTSA result next to a Latin NCAP result only when a person has reviewed the sources and classified the pair into one of four categories: same car; same generation with different equipment; different car with the same name; or no tested counterpart. Without that review, the page does not show the comparison.

How can I tell whether my car has the equipment of the tested version?

Compare your car's VIN and production date with those given in the Latin NCAP result: when optional equipment becomes standard, Latin NCAP updates the rating and states the production date and VIN from which it applies.

Each rating applies to the tested version, with the number of airbags shown in its name. According to Latin NCAP, there may be units in stock with lower safety specifications, and improvements that were not tested do not change the rating.

The VIN does not always reveal a unit's airbags or driver assistance systems. To confirm them, check the manufacturer's specification sheet for your version or ask the dealer with the VIN at hand.

Is Latin NCAP reliable?

Latin NCAP publishes how it selects, obtains and tests cars and the protocols it uses to rate them, so anyone can review the method behind each result; Vinfo.la does not issue its own opinion about the program.

According to its website, Latin NCAP was created to improve vehicle safety, following the recommendation of the United Nations Global Plan for the Decade of Action for Road Safety 2011–2020 to establish NCAP programs in every region of the world. Information about the organization is in the institutional section of its website (“Sobre nosotros”, in Spanish).

Latin NCAP selects models from the best sellers in the region and buys them from dealers like any consumer, or takes them from the production line following its protocol. The manufacturer is notified and may witness the test and respond before publication, but Latin NCAP makes the final decision on what is published.

Latin NCAP also runs a voluntary testing program in which a manufacturer sponsors the test of a model; in that case, if the car submitted has more equipment than the basic version, Latin NCAP also assesses the version with the most basic equipment.

Latin NCAP's assessment and testing protocols are published on its website, and several of the testing protocols it uses are Euro NCAP protocols.

Where does the safety data shown on Vinfo.la come from?

Vinfo.la does not crash-test cars or assign its own ratings: when it shows a crash safety result, the data comes from Latin NCAP, Euro NCAP or NHTSA, with a link to the original source and the date it was retrieved.

Vinfo.la shows each result with its test year, protocol and tested version, and never converts one program's stars into another's.

Official sources cited